Showing posts with label Euhemerism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Euhemerism. Show all posts

04 November 2026

Martin of Braga

A pilgrim from the Hungary/Austria region in Europe became an archbishop in Portugal and wrote prolifically, including a piece that was borrowed and re-written more than once for centuries afterward.

Born c.518, Martin of Dumio made a pilgrimage to the Holy Land where he became a monk. From there he joined a ship that traveled to Galicia in northern Portugal.

Galicia at the time was populated by a Germanic tribe called the Suevi, who were Christians but followed Arianism (considered heretical), and Martin brought Chalcedonian Christianity (what we now think of as Roman Catholicism) to the people.

Martin started by befriending King Theodomir of the Suevi, and ingratiated himself to the court at the Suevi capital of Braga. Using his personal connections, he persuaded the king and court to convert from Arianism. (The illustration shows Martin and King Miro of the Suevi, Theodomir's successor.)

He then founded a monastery at Dumium (and others), after which the king named him bishop of Dumium (modern Dume). In 561 he attended the First Council of Braga, which determined that the same liturgy should be used by all churches for Masses and vigils. Also, that Dominus vobiscum was how priests should greet the congregation, which should reply with Et cum spiritu tuo. (This greeting and response is lifted from the Book of Ruth 2:4.) It also condemned Priscillianism, declared that priests should not be vegetarians (a Priscillian doctrine), but if they did want to eat just vegetables, those vegetables should be cooked in meat. Astrology was soundly condemned, being also connected to Priscillianism.

Martin was named archbishop of the Diocese of Braga, hence the name by which he is more commonly known. Besides his duties, he wrote prolifically, and translated numerous treatise from Greek to present to the Suevi.

One of his works was a letter written to a bishop, De correctione rusticorum ("On the correction of rural people"). That bishop, Polemius of Astorga, had asked Martin to address the origin of idols. That letter can be seen here with Latin and English side-by-side. Martin explains pagan gods and spirits as demons and devils, allowing no credit to other divine beings except God.

This letter, an example of euhemerism, influenced Æfric of Eynsham's "On False Gods," which in turn was used by Archbishop Wulfstan of York in a similar work.

He also presided over the Second Council of Braga in 572, which I want to talk about tomorrow.

03 November 2026

On False Gods

Now that we understand Euhemerism we can look at Ælfric of Eynsham's example of it in his essay De falsis deis ("On false gods"). A handful of manuscripts survive, at least one of which is a translation from Anglo-Saxon to Old Norse.

Ælfric's goal was to explain away all the heathen stories of gods and legends and put the world into a Christian context. Archbishop Wulfstan of York (previously mentioned here) "borrowed" Ælfric's writing for his own homilies, also known as De falsis deis as well as Homily XII. Wulfstan's became very well-known and copied throughout the island. From him we have more complete versions, and we'll use it below.

Of course the problem with heathens is caused by the devil:

Alas, it is because of the devil that many things went wrong long ago, and mankind disobeyed God too greatly, and heathenism altogether did harm too greatly and still does widespread harm. However, we do not read anywhere in books that man established any idolatry anywhere in the world in the time before Noah's flood.

Then they also took it as wisdom, through the devil's teaching, to worship the sun and moon for gods because of their shiny brightness, and they made sacrifices to them that they did not know before, but learned through devil's teaching,

Some men also said that the shiny stars were gods and began some believed gods were also in fire because of the sudden heat, some also believed there were gods in water, and some believed gods were in the earth, because she nourishes all things.

Yet heathens would not be restricted to as few gods as they had before, but took to worshipping various giants and violent men of the world who became mighty in worldly powers and were awe-inspiring while they lived, and they foully followed their own desires.

He then becomes very specific:

One man was in former days living on the island that is called Crete, and he was named Saturn, and he was so savage that he did away with his own children, all except one, and unlike a father he destroyed their lives in their youth.

He nevertheless reluctantly left one alive (though he did away with his brothers) who he was called Jove, and he became a savage fiend. He expelled his own father from the same aforementioned island called Crete, and he would have destroyed him eagerly if he could. This Jove became so wanton that he took his own sister as his wife; she was named Juno, and she became a greatly exalted goddess according to heathen reckoning.

He continues to explain away the named deities of the Classical Era:

There was also a man called Mercury, he was very crafty and deceitful in deed and trickeries, though his speech was fully clever. The heathens made him a renowned god for themselves; ... This false god was honored among the heathens in that day, and he is also called by the name Odin in the Danish manner. Now some of the Danish men say in their error that he, whom they call Thor, was Jove, the son of Mercury, whom they call Odin—but they are not right, for we read in books, both in heathen and in Christian ones, that the evil Jove is, in truth, Saturn's son. 

There was also a woman named Venus; she was Jove's daughter and she was so foul and wicked in lust that she copulated with her own brother, or so the men say, through the devil's teaching, and the heathens also worshipped that evil woman as an exalted woman.

Wulfstan's copying of Æfric's work was only fair, since Ælfric himself based his version on a 6th-century sermon by Martin of Braga. Let's check out Martin tomorrow and see what else he did.

02 November 2026

Euhemerism

I said yesterday that I was going to talk about the writings of Ælfric of Eynsham, and I will, but I want to explain the term Euhemerism first. Euhemerism is an attempt to shed light on mythology by interpreting it as springing from actual historical events. Or, in the words of an American historian, it is "the taking of a cosmic god and placing him at a definite point in history as an actual person who was later deified." 

It assumes that real events became exaggerated and fictionalized in the oral transmission. The term comes from a late 4th-century BCE Greek, Euhemerus, who tried to rationalize mythology. Many early Greek philosophers were in agreement. In Plato's Phaedrus, Socrates offers an explanation of the story of an Athenian princess "taken away" by the north wind, Boreas. Socrates points out the place where there is a temple to Boreas where a wind might have knocked a young woman off her feet and onto rocks where she was killed.

Early Christian apologists used Euhemerism against paganism by declaring:

That those are no gods whom the common people worship, is known from this: they were formerly kings, who on account of their royal memory subsequently began to be adored by their people even in death. Thence temples were founded to them; thence images were sculptured to retain the countenances of the deceased by the likeness; and men sacrificed victims, and celebrated festal days, by way of giving them honour. Thence to posterity those rites became sacred, which at first had been adopted as a consolation.[from St. Cyprian]

The Middle Ages, and writers like Vincent of Beauvais and Roger Bacon, were willing to believe that supernatural beings were not imaginary, but were part of the natural order of things created by God. Men like Marsilius Ficino produced encyclopedic works to explain the hierarchy of demons, spirits, angels, archangels, etc., in God's creation.

Snorri Sturluson's Prose Edda (c.1220) paints the Norse gods as great leaders and kings, tracing back to that great foundation of so much medieval culture, the Trojan War.

The Modern Era also sometimes looks for historic origins of legendary characters, exaggerating them. Dracula, Paul Bunyan, Robin Hood—searching for the kernel of truth that grew into a legend.

But tomorrow we'll talk about Ælfric of Eynsham. Promise.