21 November 2026

Gregory's Principles

Not only were there specific principles put forth during the pontificate of Pope Gregory VII that are known as the Gregorian Reforms, there were also a series of principles that he produced in 1075 known as the dictation of the Pope (Dictatus papae).

The list (seen here) was not a formally published declaration; it was a list (presumably dictated) by the pope of the principles he and previous popes had made.

All of these are steps leading to the the nation of the pope's supremacy and infallibility, which would culminate in Boniface VIII's bull Unam Sanctam. Here are a few of those steps:

II. That the Roman pontiff alone is called universal by right.

VII. That for him alone is it licit, according to the necessity of time to establish new laws, to welcome new peoples, to make new abbacies of canonical right and, contrariwise, to divide rich bishoprics and unite needy ones.

IX. That all princes are to kiss the feet of the pope alone.

XII. That for him it is licit to depose emperors.

XVI. That no synod without his precept ought to be called general.

XIX. That he himself must be judged by no one.

XXII. That the Roman church has never erred nor will ever err in perpetuity, as scripture testifies.

Some of these could almost be called the Hildebrand Reforms, because long before he became pope Gregory was the top papal administrator for many years; in that position he pushed for many of these ideas. Some of this was during the papacy of Nicholas II, whom we should get to know. See you tomorrow.

20 November 2026

The Gregorian Reforms

Of the popes named Gregory, the Gregorian Reforms did not come from the one called Gregory the Great (c.540 - 12 March 604). The Reforms were instituted by the 11th-century Gregory VII, who ruled the Church from 1073 to 1085. To be fair, Gregory VII claimed in writing that his attempt at improving the moral integrity of the Church and clergy was in honor of Gregory I "the Great."

(The Gregorian Calendar reform was under Pope Gregory XIII, in the 16th century.)

His goal seems to have been pulling the Church back from the way it was intertwined with secular authorities during the Carolingian Era. Famously, Pope Leo III crowned Charlemagne on Christmas Day 800, starting a debate over who had the higher authority, either secular or religious figures. But the Carolingians exercised a lot of control over local priests and parishes. Gregory did not want spiritual authority subject to temporal authority.

The Gregorian Reforms were largely in four areas, starting with Investiture.

1. Investing of a cleric was no longer to be made by a secular authority. Investiture was always to be the prerogative of the religious powers.

2. Church property was to be opened by the Church or clergy, not a layman. (This prevented the layman from collecting revenues off the property.)

3. Simony, the act of selling Church positions or religious objects such a relics to the highest bidder, was forbidden.

4. The marriage of priests, which blended the priest's sacred duties with temporal actions that were far from spiritual, was seen as the cause of moral decadence in priests. 

Gregory was also the author of many additional statements, many of which still pertain. I'll share some of those tomorrow.

19 November 2026

Gregory's Papacy

Years after Hildebrand of Sovana became Pope Gregory VII, complaints rose about the irregularity of his election. Gregory himself pointed out how the event contradicted the papacy's own rules.

In 607 CE, the rule was set forth that a pope could not be elected sooner than three days after his predecessor's burial. Also, the shouts to elect him were begun from a pulpit during the funeral of Alexander II by Ugo Candidus, a Cardinal Priest. The Constitution of Pope Nicholas II determined that only a Cardinal Bishop could nominate a candidate. Also, the Holy Roman Emperor was supposed to be consulted.

By acknowledging these irregularities early in his reign he helped to defuse any suggestion that he was trying to cover up a coup. He also wrote to Holy Roman Emperor Henry IV of Germany, asking for his approval. The funeral for Alexander II was 21 April 1073. Gregory was acting as pope shortly after, but was was only solemnly consecrated on the Feast of Sts. Peter and Paul, 29 June, after approval came from Henry.

This was the last time a papal election ever looked for approval from the emperor.

The relationship between pope and emperor reached its peak during Gregory's reign. The Investiture Controversy and the famous Walk to Canossa have been discussed elsewhere.

Gregory didn't just clash with the secular powers over the pope's authority. He also tackled what he saw as systemic problems in the Church itself, and in its clergy. Tomorrow we'll look at the Gregorian Reforms that altered the course of the Church.

18 November 2026

Pope Gregory VII

I most recently mentioned Pope Gregory VII (reigned 1073 - 1085) regarding his statement that priests should not be keeping their families in Church-owned housing. He was also firmly involved in the ongoing Investiture controversy.

He was born Hildebrand of Sovana in southern Tuscany. He started as the son of a blacksmith, but was sent to Rome to study at an abbey where (it is said) his uncle was abbot. One of his teachers was the future Pope Gregory VI. Gregory VI became pope in May 1045 and resigned from that position in December 1046. He went to Germany, and Hildebrand went with him.

Hildebrand is believed to have spent a year at Cluny. After the death of Gregory VI in 1048, Hildebrand returned to Rome with the abbot of Cluny, Bruno. Bruno was elected pope and took the name Leo IX. Leo appointed Hildebrand a deacon and administrator in his papacy.

When Leo died in 1054, Pope Victor II confirmed Hildebrand as a papal legate. Victor was followed by Pope Stephen IX, who sent Hildebrand and Anselm of Lucca on a mission to meet with Agnes of Poitou, Holy Roman Empress.

After returning to Rome, Hildebrand was caught up in the controversy over the election of antipope Benedict X (who was supported by Agnes). Hildebrand actually led a force of 300 Norman knights sent by Richard Drengot, Count of Aversa (in southern Italy) to capture the castle to which Benedict had fled.

By 1059 Hildebrand had been made an archdeacon and was the most important man in the papal administration. His influence helped get Anselm of Lucca elected as Pope Alexander II. Alexander instituted some reforms that had been proposed by Hildebrand. Hildebrand was crucial to reconciling with the Norman kingdom of southern Italy. Another of the reforms established that the pope was to be elected by the college of cardinals, not chosen by any secular ruler.

Ironically, that is not what happened when Hildebrand became pope.

During the funeral service for Alexander II, on 21 April 1073, the people and clergy started a chant to "Let Hildebrand be pope!" Hildebrand fled the scene; he could not support such an irregular method of choosing a pope, and wanted to show that he was having none of it. The people had to go searching for him, finally finding him at a church named after the first pope, Peter (was it a symbolic move to show that he was interested in the job?). The cardinals assembled there and made the election more formal.

He chose the regnal name Gregory in honor of his mentor. Tomorrow we'll see how his papacy went.

17 November 2026

Pope Celestine III

Celestine was very fond of threatening excommunication against European rulers during his barely seven years as pope, but sometimes it was for good reasons.

Born Giacinto Bobone c.1105 into a noble Roman family. He was a student of Peter Abelard. He was made a cardinal-deacon in 1144. He was sent on missions to Spain, having earned a reputation for expertise on the peninsula. The same year he became pope, in 1191, he condemned King Alfonso IX of León for his marriage to Theresa of Portugal, Alfonso's first cousin. That marriage was declared null, but they had two daughters first.

In 1196 Celestine saw fit to excommunicate Alfonso outright for his alliance with non-Christians, the Almohad Caliphate. This alliance was to help León attack King Alfonso VIII of Castile. Castile and León reconciled, but the approach they took angered Celestine even more: Alfonso's son, Alfonso the IX, was married to Berengaria of Castle to cement a relationship between the two kingdoms. Consanguinity, however, was still the problem (the two were first cousins, once removed), so León was placed under Interdict, forbidding Christians from Mass and the other sacraments (except Baptism and Last Rites).

Celestine also crowned Henry VI as Holy Roman Emperor. He later wanted to excommunicate Henry for keeping Richard I of England imprisoned on behalf of Leopold V of Austria. (Richard was on his way home from the Crusade when Leopold nabbed him. Leopold blamed Richard for the murder of Conrad of Montferrat, Leopold's cousin. Henry was happy to help because he blamed Richard for siding with Tancred of Sicily over a claim to ruling Sicily through Henry's wife.)

Excommunicating someone who had been made Holy Roman Emperor was a bold move, and the college of cardinals was against it, so Celestine ultimately chose not to. But he did threaten to excommunicate Duke Valdemar and place Denmark under Interdict because Valdemar had imprisoned a bishop. The bishop stayed in prison until 1203 when Innocent managed the situation.

In 1198, in his 90s, Celestine tried to resign the papacy and name his own successor, but again the cardinals prevented him from carrying out his wishes. He died on 8 January 1198. Some of what we know of him comes from the biography written by Pope Honorius III, who also wrote a biography of Pope Gregory VII. We'll look at Gregory next time.

16 November 2026

Pope Honorius III

Pope Honorius III has been woven into this blog many times, from being the tutor (in 1197) to the man who became Holy Roman Emperor Frederick II, to giving permission to Dominic Guzman to found a new order, to forbidding clergy to practice civil law, and more. It's time to learn about the man himself.

Born Cencio Savelli c.1150 into a powerful aristocratic family, he was a canon for a time before becoming the Camerlengo of the Holy Roman Church. The Camerlengo oversees property and revenues for the papacy, a position that still exists (now the Camerlengo is always a cardinal). Pope Celestine III made Cencio a cardinal in 1200.

When Innocent died on 16 July 1216, the college of cardinals were concerned that disagreements could create a schism. They appointed two cardinals to make a choice of a compromise candidate. Cencio Savelli was their choice, although he did not want tohe job. Still, he accepted their wishes and was crowned pope on 31 August.

One of his first big tasks was to prepare the Fifth Crusade. It had been declared by Innocent in 1215, and the preparations required money. Cardinals and the Pope pledged a tenth of their income for three years; other clergy were to pledge one-twentieth. This would still not be sufficient to mount a Crusade, however.

In April 1217, Honorius crowned Peter II of Courtenay as Latin Emperor of Constantinople, which might have caused Peter to donate generously to the Crusade. Peter had a problem, however, when he was captured on his way to Constantinople by the despot of Epirus, Theodore Komnenos Doukas. (Epirus was a "rump state" established after the disastrous Fourth Crusade sacked Constantinople.) Peter died in captivity.

Béla III of Hungary had vowed to go on Crusade. He had died, so Honorius appealed to his son, Andrew II of Hungary, to fulfill his father's vow and contribute. Frederick II, Honorius' old tutee, also promised to get involved, but kept delaying.  In fact, most European rulers had their own wars to deal with. Leaving their homes and diverting military resources to a Crusade was not impractical.

Another concern of Honorius was the existence of heretical Catharism in southern France, and of the Iberian Peninsula occupied by Muslims. He also wanted to spread Christianity around and beyond the Baltic Sea.

To help spread Christianity and root out heresy, he was glad to give his support to new religious orders. He approved the Dominicans in 1216, the Franciscans in 1223, and the Carmelite Order in 1226.

Honorius prized education, and wanted the clergy to be learned men. He withheld approval of a bishop-elect at Chartres because the man did not have sufficient knowledge to be given that authority. He dismissed another bishop for being illiterate.

Honorius died on 18 March 1227. He was succeeded by Gregory IX.

Honorius displayed his own erudition with his writings. He produced several works, including biographies of Celestine III and Gregory VII. It turns out that those are two additional popes whose names show up in this blog over the years but only as participants in other people's stories. Let's see what they were like, starting tomorrow.

15 November 2026

Langton and John

Now that King John of England and Pope Innocent III had reconciled, Stephen Langton was allowed to take his place as Archbishop of Canterbury and John had a powerful ally in the pope. As Archbishop he absolved the king of his past wrongdoings. John swore that unjust laws would be repealed.

John did not follow through on that promise. When the barons of England rebelled against the absolute power held by the king, Langton supported them. On 25 August 1213, Langton read aloud to a group of churchmen and barons a charter from King Henry I. This charter granted several liberties (even to Jews, who followed William the Conqueror to England after 1066 and were recognized as valuable sources of money). This Charter of Liberties also allowed more Church rights.

The Charter had been curtailed by royal decrees since the time of Henry, and the barons and Langton wanted them restored. John's refusal to do so led ultimately to John being forced to sign the Magna Carta in June 1215, upholding these rights. This he refused to uphold the rights, which then led to the First Baron's War. (The illustration is one of the four surviving original copies of the Magna Carta with John's signature.)

Remember, however, that the pope was now John's liege lord, and wanted to support his vassal. Despite the fact that the Charter and Magna Carta allowed Church rights as well, Innocent decided it was appropriate to excommunicate the barons. This decision was sent to Langton, who chose not to pronounce the writ of excommunication.

John knew from the pope that the excommunication was supposed to take place, and so John forbade Langton to perform any of his ecclesiastical functions. Langton went to the pope for support, but Innocent confirmed John's decision. This was on 4 November 1215. Langton was released from his suspension in the spring, but told to stay out of England while the First Barons War was running its course.

What did Innocent gain from this? Well, the £700 annually promised by John. A new regime might decide to stop being the pope's vassal.

Innocent died 16 July 1216. John died on 19 October 1216. Hubert de Burgh immediately went to John's nine-year-old son Henry to keep him safe.

There was the push to crown him immediately. Normally this would be done at Westminster by the Archbishop of Canterbury, but Langton was (of course) out of the country at Pontigny Abbey. There was also no crown (having been lost by John along with many treasures). The boy was knighted by William Marshal, he was anointed by Bishops Sylvester of Worcester and Simon of Exeter, and a gold circlet owned by his mother was placed on his head by Peter des Roches. The event was overseen by the papal legate Cardinal Guala Bicchieri.

During the coronation, Henry paid homage to the papacy, in this case Pope Honorius III. Honorius had a different attitude toward England than Innocent's. I'll talk about him next time.

14 November 2026

The Threat of France

The excommunication of King John and the Interdict of England by Pope Innocent III was not creating enough pressure on John to allow Stephen Langton to take his rightful place as Archbishop of Canterbury. Innocent prepared letters (never sent) that are evidence that he might have been asking King Philip II of France to depose John.

Perhaps John knew of this threat. Perhaps it was internal political pressure from the barons of England, but eventually John realized he needed to reconcile with the pope and lift the Interdict and excommunication. This meant, of course, accepting Langton as archbishop.

In May 1213, John accepted the terms of reconciliation from the papal legate Pandulf Verraccio. It was Verraccio who had formally declared the writ of excommunication in John's presence. Now, in 1213, John formally handed all of England to the pope, and the pope returned it to John as a papal fief. (The illustration is by William Blake in 1797, showing John humbling himself before Pandulf.)

There was more, and the arrangement is recorded as the Bulla Aurea ("Golden Bull"; there is more than one agreement referred to by this title). It included annual tribute to the papacy from England of £700 (£500 from England, £200 from Ireland). He also had to compensate the Church for the revenues he had confiscated during the Interdict.

This meant that the pope was John's liege lord to whom he owed obedience. John went further than was probably necessary, but it would benefit him in the future. Now he had the pope behind him to prevent France from attacking. The pope would not allow another country to try to take over a country that was his. John had the pope's support for the rest of his reign (although that did not prevent the Barons' Wars).

But Langton was finally seated. Let's look at the rest of his career, and whether he and John were able to put aside the past and work together for the good of England. Short answer to that question: yes. Longer answer: well, they may have had different ideas of what "good" for England meant.

13 November 2026

King John Excommunicated

King John of England wanted John de Gray for Archbishop of Canterbury, but Pope Innocent III consecrated Stephen Langton after a disputed election by the cathedral chapter of Canterbury. John would not allow Langton to enter Canterbury, and so the pope put the country under Interdict.

The Interdict started March 1208, and meant that priests were not allowed to perform church services. This was devastating to a devout population. It was not a complete shutting down of the sacraments, however. Concerned about people's souls, baptisms and last rites for the dying (confession and being granted absolution) were allowed, lest innocent people go to Hell.

John (shown here with his dogs) treated the Interdict as an act of war and became hostile to priests in England. Some priests were willing to ignore the Interdict and perform services; those who were obedient to the pope had their estates seized. John also arrested priests' concubines, requiring fines to get them released. Some priests fled England, and John confiscated their property.

Pope Innocent threatened John with personal excommunication if he did not stop his assault on priests and his refusal to allow Langton to take his position in Canterbury. John stood his ground and was excommunicated in November 1209.

Although this was considered a powerful weapon wielded by the Church, there was recent evidence that it was not that damaging to a ruler. Emperor Otto IV and Count Raymond VI of Toulouse (both allies of John) had been excommunicated by Innocent and survived the process. (Otto had killed a rival; Raymond was considered too lenient about the Cathars.)

John simply continued to absorb the revenue from confiscated church lands. Although his barons would rebel soon and force him to sign the Magna Carta, limiting his executive power, the country did not rebel against him during this time. The Church was losing money, the people were suffering spiritually, and Innocent started making exceptions. Monasteries were allowed to perform Mass. The Eucharist could be offered as part of Last Rites. Burial in Christian ground was taking place anyway.

Then John was threatened from another direction, one he couldn't ignore. It appears the pope was preparing to ask someone else to intervene with England on behalf of the Church.

France.

This was a more serious threat to John's throne. I'll tell you how it turned out tomorrow.

12 November 2026

Stephen Langton

Stephen Langton has been mentioned before, ordering English Jews to wear a white band, helping Barons draft what would become the Magna Carta, being asked by Pope Honorius to give a religious position to alchemist Michael Scot, and helping Hubert de Burgh manage the kingdom of England for the child Henry III.

He was born c.1150, the son of a lord of a manor in Lincolnshire. He studied at the University of Paris, staying there for 25 years and becoming known as a great lecturer and theologian. Pope Innocent III summoned him to Rome and made him cardinal-priest (below a cardinal-bishop but higher than a cardinal-deacon) of St. Chrysogonus in Rome.

When Archbishop of Canterbury Hubert Walter died in 1205, there was disagreement over his successor. Two different groups of canons of the cathedral chapter elected different men, but Innocent refused to consecrate either and ordered a new election. Sixteen canons had traveled to Rome to plead their case, and they were given the chance to make a decision on behalf of the whole chapter.

The choice they fell on was Stephen Langton; Innocent consecrated him on 17 June 1207. Possibly he was suggested and supported by Innocent, but he was considered the foremost English theologian. Innocent and King John clashed over this, since John had wanted John de Grey, Bishop of Norwich.

King John banished the monks of Canterbury, seized all their revenue, and refused to allow Langton to enter Canterbury. The pope replied by putting all of England under Interdict in March 1208, meaning no one could administer the sacraments.

Langton sailed to Dover to try to meet with John in October 1209, but John would not travel the whole way to meet him, and Langton went back to the continent after waiting a week. He stayed at Pontigny Abbey in Burgundy, where Thomas Becket had also stayed on his exile from England under King John's father, Henry II. Edmund of Abingdon also stayed there in his way to Rome.

In November 1209, John was excommunicated for his denial of Langton. This was serious. We'll continue tomorrow.

11 November 2026

The Men Helping the Jews, Part 3

That title is not meant to justify or praise the men of whom I'm speaking. At the time it was thought by Christians that the best approach to dealing with the "problem" of Jews was to kill them or force them to be Christian.

Yesterday I discussed Walter Mauclerc, bishop of Carlisle and first warden of the Domus Conversorum. Today is about Peter des Roches, a soldier and diplomat from Poitou who served King John and then Henry III. He also spent time on the Sixth Crusade (1228 - 1229).

In 1205 he was named bishop of Winchester by John, though he seemed unsuitable. Pope Innocent III confirmed him for John's sake. Peter stayed loyal to John when Innocent placed England under interdict because John did not want to accept Stephen Langton as Archbishop of Canterbury.

Peter's loyalty prompted John to name him Chief Justiciar (equivalent to prime minister), but by 1215 he was replaced with Hubert de Burgh, one of the other witnesses to the charter establishing the Domus Conversorum. des Roches also led opposition to de Burgh on behalf of the barons.

He founded several monasteries, and when Dominicans first came to England in 1221 he supported them.

Peter des Roches (like Hubert de Burgh and Walter Mauclerc) eventually fell out of favor with Henry, in his case in 1234. He died in 1238.

There is an odd legend about des Roches in the Lanercost Chronicle, a history covering 1201 to 1346. It records that des Roches was out hunting and came upon King Arthur. The two dined together, and des Roches asked for a token from Arthur so that he could prove that they had met. Arthur told him to close his hand and open it again. When he did so, a butterfly appeared. The Chronicle says that des Roches could repeat this trick for the rest of his life.

As for the issue with John and Stephen Langton, I should explain that more next time.

10 November 2026

The Men Helping the Jews, Part 2

Yesterday's post mentioned three witnesses to King Henry III's charter that established the Domus Conversorum. Hubert de Burgh has been discussed before, but Mauclerc and des Roches have not. All three served in positions under Henry's father, King John.

Thirty years before this 1232 charter, Mauclerc showed up as a clerk in Normandy, then having his own church. A year later, however, he is in England and holding a prebend (a portion of the revenue of a church) in Exeter.

He collected taxes for John, who also sent him to Rome as an envoy to Pope Innocent III. Loyal to John, one of his jobs in Rome was to make sure Innocent did not give support to any English barons who might turn to the pope for help against the king. In 1223 he was elevated to be bishop of Carlisle.

As bishop of Carlisle, he came into a very handsome property, Rose Castle (the illustration is recent, but at the time it was likely wooden). Henry's grandfather, Henry II, had confiscated Rose Castle from a man who irritated him. It was still a royal possession, and Henry III handed it off to Mauclerc in 1230.

Mauclerc was part of the embassy in 1225 to arrange marriage between Henry and the daughter of the Duke of Austria. (That marriage did not happen.) In 1228 he was named the royal Treasurer for life, but in 1233 he was expelled from that office and replaced with Peter des Rivaux, the nephew of Peter des Roches. He was the first warden of the Domus Conversorum.

Peter des Roches' influence on the king that caused Mauclerc's removal from office would be reversed when des Roches himself fell from grace, and Mauclerc returned to the king's court. In June 1246 he resigned the bishopric and retired to Oxford, joining a Dominican community there. He died in October 1248 in Oxford, His will left his personal property to Carlisle and to the Dominicans.

Tomorrow we'll look at the other witness to the Domus Conversorum charter, Peter des Roches.

09 November 2026

The Men Helping the Jews

Helping them to become Christians, that is. One of my first posts on this blog in the early days was about the Domus Conversorum, the "House of Converts." King Henry III wanted to turn Jews to Christianity, but because he would require them to leave behind their lands and careers, he offered to house, clothe, and feed them.

A charter was produced in January 1232 and began

From King Henry Greetings:

"Know that we, in the sight of God, and for our souls, and for the sake of our predecessors and heirs, have granted and confirmed by this our charter, for us and our heirs, eternally to God and to the glorious Virgin Mary, and to the church, the house of the converts which we founded in the suburbs of London. Namely, a village called New Street, in honor of the same Virgin, and to the converts who reside there and who will reside in the future, seven hundred marks to support those converts and to make the construction of their church and their buildings, to be received every year to our treasury, that is to say, one half to the Easter treasury, and another half to the treasury of St. Michael, until we or the heirs of the same converts shall provide more abundantly in lands or rents, assigned to them in a certain place, from which they can competently support themselves and their families to the honor of God and the aforesaid glorious Virgin."

 There was more, but it ended with

Witnessed,
P. Winton, Bishop
W. Carl, Bishop
H. De Burgh

These were Peter des Roches Bishop of Winchester, Walter Mauclerc Bishop of Carlisle, and Hubert de Burgh, Chief Justiciar and one of the most important men in the kingdom who would fall out with Henry later in 1232. William Mauclerc was the first warden (custos) of the Domus Conversorum, responsible for the proper running of the place and the man to whom they could bring grievances.

I've discussed de Burgh's place in Henry's reign before. I want to talk about Mauclerc and des Roches tomorrow.

N.B. The Domus Conversorum has a special place in my heart. I first learned about it while researching my first Chaucer mystery, A Death in Catte Street. For years I kept asking myself why anyone would give up their whole former life and identity for pauper's wages and dormitory living.  Many scholarly books have been written about the place, and we even have England's records of the names of those who were baptized and entered. There are also records of grievances the residents brought to the king. In have written two novels, each 100,000 words (and each with numerous footnotes), about life for these residents, their challenges getting along, adapting to their new lifestyle and new religion, and challenges in dealing with the outside world. In 2027 I hope to bring these to publication and introduce people to a little-known part of English and religious history.

08 November 2026

The Twelfth Council of Toledo

Visigothic King Erwig called a council on 9 January 681, the Twelfth Council of Toledo. Part of his reason was to have the bishops attending confirm his accession to the throne to replace Wamba as legitimate. The Council also declared that laws created by Wamba were null and void.

They then set about to revise the Visigothic Code that had been established in 654 by King Reccesuinth (seen here), called the Liber Iudiciorum, or "Book of Judgements." That code had abolished the idea of treating Romans and Goths differently under the law and made consistent rules for everyone to live by.

This code also contained canon law from the Catholic Church as well as secular laws. Some of the religious laws are attributed to the influence of Julian of Toledo, archbishop of Toledo (and implicated in the plot—if that is what it was—to replace Wamba with Erwig).

The Council affirmed the right of the archbishop of Toledo to approve all bishops across the entire Visigothic kingdom. (Once again suggesting Julian of Toledo's strong hand in these decisions.)

There were rules on penance, and the proper conduct for bishops and priests. Then it created 28 rules regarding Jews. (The illustration is a synagogue in Toledo.)

Erwig wanted what he called the "plague" of the Jews eradicated. He did change earlier laws to rule out execution, however. (The Eighth Council had declared a converted Jew who practiced his old religion would be put to death.) The goal was to convert them to Christianity. If they refused to convert, then they were prohibited from celebrating their religious feasts, following Jewish dietary laws, performing circumcisions, working on Sundays (Saturday was the Jewish sabbath), or marrying without a priest's blessing.

To assure this, Jews were monitored. They were prevented from leaving the country, and required to "check in" regularly with a bishop. The Council ordered confiscation of Jewish property. If Jews had purchased anything of value from Christians, they had to re-sell it back at a lower price.

Catholics who aided Jews were fined.

Once converted, however, it was important to prevent them from reverting to their old customs. On Jewish holidays, converts were required to appear in public in places where the Jewish festivals were not being celebrated, to prove that they were not reverting to their old practices.

Centuries later, England had a slightly more accommodating way to deal with Jews who convert to Christianity. I'll tell you more tomorrow.

King Erwig

Visigothic King Wamba ruled from 672 to 680, when something happened to him. There are different stories about how he ended his reign. The main one is that he fell ill, took up monastic vows to save his soul while on his supposed deathbed, then recovered, but could not renounce the vows and had to abdicate.

Two centuries later a historian said he was poisoned and ill, but had to step down after recovering. Another version is that he slept (possibly being given a sleeping potion), whereupon Erwig shaved his head. A shaved head meant he was not allowed to rule, but he was glad to step away from the responsibility and join a monastery, where he lived until he died in 687. It was said that he named Erwig as his successor.

The abdication took place on 14 October. His successor, Erwig, was anointed king on 31 October—rather quickly.

A few months later, Erwig opened the Twelfth Council of Toledo. The Council confirmed that the abdication of Wamba and succession of Erwig were legitimate, but historians think the speed with which Erwig was anointed suggest there was a plan all along to replace Wamba. A later story suggests that Julian of Toledo, a monk who was (suspiciously) named Primate of the Visigothic Church by Erwig, was involved in administering whatever was given to Wamba to incapacitate him..

Erwig had married the daughter of an earlier Visigothic king, but his appointment was viewed with suspicion by the nobles. A Thirteenth Council of Toledo in 683 and a Fourteenth Council in 684 were called to (among other things), confirm Erwig's legitimacy and to pass laws to protect him and his queen and family.

The Twelfth Council also eliminated Wamba's attempt to create a diocese whose bishop would be episcopus sub regula, "a bishop under a rule" who would not have the secular power of typical bishops.

Something held in common by Erwig and Wamba and the Twelfth Council of Toledo was their hatred of the Jews. We will examine that tomorrow.

06 November 2026

King Wamba

When the Third Council of Braga was held in 675 (a century after the Second), the Visigothic king at the time tried to influence it.

Wamba, whose name means "big paunch," became king in 672. He had an immediate double revolt to deal with. A rival for the kingship, Hilderic the governor of Nîmes in southern France, rebelled but was suppressed by a general named Paul sent by Wamba.

That general, however, convinced the men under him to renounce their loyalty to the king and support Paul himself instead. He started calling himself Flavius Paulus, and the followers of Hilderic and others joined him. Soon he had many followers in southern France and northern Spain, and was calling himself "King of the East."

Wamba marched from his location in Cantabria in northern Spain to Paul's location and fairly quickly regained control of the region and people. Paul retreated to Nîmes, but didn't last long. A year after Wamba ascended to the throne, the revolts had been put down, Nîmes had been (re-)captured, and Paul and his chief leaders were put on trial, convicted, and sent to prison for life after being scalped.

Religious leaders had supported Paul as well, particularly the Bishop of Maguelohne. Wamba was a reformist when it came to the Church, and he wanted to make a change in the power structure. He tried to found a new diocese on monastic principles, whose bishop would be episcopus sub regula, "a bishop under a rule" who would not have the secular power of typical bishops.

This was a manner of diocesan practice in early Iberian church structure under the Visigoths and Suevi. In it, the bishop and clergy would live ascetic lives. The best-known example was St. Fructuosus of Braga.

The Third Council of Braga repeated the Second's decree that bishops should not take fees for ordaining a priest, and rectors of churches must not use their household to do work on their privately owned farms unless they paid them properly. This was in line with Wamba's aim of simpler living for the clergy in his kingdom.

A few years later, however, the Twelfth Council of Toledo had a different opinion. I'll tell you about the transition from Wamba to his successor tomorrow.

05 November 2026

The Second Council of Braga

There were several religious councils held at Braga, the 11th of which took place as late as 1566. (The illustration is Braga at the time of the last Council.) We talked about the First yesterday. The Second Council, held in 572 only 11 years after the first, wanted not only to formalize some of the practices of the clergy, it addressed behaviors of the clergy and bishops.

There were ten decrees from the Second Council, and they laid out some things that seem so appropriate that one wonders that they were necessary.

The first says simply that bishops need to make sure that priests are performing the rituals and sacraments properly. Makes sense. Number two is quite simple: a bishop must not be tyrannical towards his priests. Well, that was unexpected.

Then the council addressed matters beneficial to the clergy and preventing the bishop from taking advantage of them. There should be no fee charged for entering Holy Orders, no fee for distributing holy chrism, no fee for consecrating a church. It sounds like some bishops were making money from their duties.

No church was to be consecrated unless the bishop determined that those managing it were appropriate. And a church built on private property was okay, unless it was set up so that the landowner could receive payment from those using it.

A priest who accused someone of "unchastity" needed evidence of two or three witnesses; otherwise, that priest should be excommunicated.

The metropolitan (highest-ranking bishop, determined by the First Council as the earliest ordained bishop), would declare the date of Easter. This would be shared after Christmas, so that people could prepare for Lent. (This was years before the Synod of Whitby and the official debate to determine the proper date for Easter.)

Number ten said that fasting was mandatory for a priest before saying Mass, lest he be deprived of his office. Lack of fasting was a Priscillian practice, and stamping out that heresy was important.

Years later, Pope Innocent III (c.1160 – 16 July 1216) gave his approval to the Second Council's declarations.

The Third Council of Braga took place a little more than a century later, and this time the king of the Visigoths was very interested in reforming the church. 'll tell you about the council and King Wamba next time.

04 November 2026

Martin of Braga

A pilgrim from the Hungary/Austria region in Europe became an archbishop in Portugal and wrote prolifically, including a piece that was borrowed and re-written more than once for centuries afterward.

Born c.518, Martin of Dumio made a pilgrimage to the Holy Land where he became a monk. From there he joined a ship that traveled to Galicia in northern Portugal.

Galicia at the time was populated by a Germanic tribe called the Suevi, who were Christians but followed Arianism (considered heretical), and Martin brought Chalcedonian Christianity (what we now think of as Roman Catholicism) to the people.

Martin started by befriending King Theodomir of the Suevi, and ingratiated himself to the court at the Suevi capital of Braga. Using his personal connections, he persuaded the king and court to convert from Arianism. (The illustration shows Martin and King Miro of the Suevi, Theodomir's successor.)

He then founded a monastery at Dumium (and others), after which the king named him bishop of Dumium (modern Dume). In 561 he attended the First Council of Braga, which determined that the same liturgy should be used by all churches for Masses and vigils. Also, that Dominus vobiscum was how priests should greet the congregation, which should reply with Et cum spiritu tuo. (This greeting and response is lifted from the Book of Ruth 2:4.) It also condemned Priscillianism, declared that priests should not be vegetarians (a Priscillian doctrine), but if they did want to eat just vegetables, those vegetables should be cooked in meat. Astrology was soundly condemned, being also connected to Priscillianism.

Martin was named archbishop of the Diocese of Braga, hence the name by which he is more commonly known. Besides his duties, he wrote prolifically, and translated numerous treatise from Greek to present to the Suevi.

One of his works was a letter written to a bishop, De correctione rusticorum ("On the correction of rural people"). That bishop, Polemius of Astorga, had asked Martin to address the origin of idols. That letter can be seen here with Latin and English side-by-side. Martin explains pagan gods and spirits as demons and devils, allowing no credit to other divine beings except God.

This letter, an example of euhemerism, influenced Æfric of Eynsham's "On False Gods," which in turn was used by Archbishop Wulfstan of York in a similar work.

He also presided over the Second Council of Braga in 572, which I want to talk about tomorrow.

03 November 2026

On False Gods

Now that we understand Euhemerism we can look at Ælfric of Eynsham's example of it in his essay De falsis deis ("On false gods"). A handful of manuscripts survive, at least one of which is a translation from Anglo-Saxon to Old Norse.

Ælfric's goal was to explain away all the heathen stories of gods and legends and put the world into a Christian context. Archbishop Wulfstan of York (previously mentioned here) "borrowed" Ælfric's writing for his own homilies, also known as De falsis deis as well as Homily XII. Wulfstan's became very well-known and copied throughout the island. From him we have more complete versions, and we'll use it below.

Of course the problem with heathens is caused by the devil:

Alas, it is because of the devil that many things went wrong long ago, and mankind disobeyed God too greatly, and heathenism altogether did harm too greatly and still does widespread harm. However, we do not read anywhere in books that man established any idolatry anywhere in the world in the time before Noah's flood.

Then they also took it as wisdom, through the devil's teaching, to worship the sun and moon for gods because of their shiny brightness, and they made sacrifices to them that they did not know before, but learned through devil's teaching,

Some men also said that the shiny stars were gods and began some believed gods were also in fire because of the sudden heat, some also believed there were gods in water, and some believed gods were in the earth, because she nourishes all things.

Yet heathens would not be restricted to as few gods as they had before, but took to worshipping various giants and violent men of the world who became mighty in worldly powers and were awe-inspiring while they lived, and they foully followed their own desires.

He then becomes very specific:

One man was in former days living on the island that is called Crete, and he was named Saturn, and he was so savage that he did away with his own children, all except one, and unlike a father he destroyed their lives in their youth.

He nevertheless reluctantly left one alive (though he did away with his brothers) who he was called Jove, and he became a savage fiend. He expelled his own father from the same aforementioned island called Crete, and he would have destroyed him eagerly if he could. This Jove became so wanton that he took his own sister as his wife; she was named Juno, and she became a greatly exalted goddess according to heathen reckoning.

He continues to explain away the named deities of the Classical Era:

There was also a man called Mercury, he was very crafty and deceitful in deed and trickeries, though his speech was fully clever. The heathens made him a renowned god for themselves; ... This false god was honored among the heathens in that day, and he is also called by the name Odin in the Danish manner. Now some of the Danish men say in their error that he, whom they call Thor, was Jove, the son of Mercury, whom they call Odin—but they are not right, for we read in books, both in heathen and in Christian ones, that the evil Jove is, in truth, Saturn's son. 

There was also a woman named Venus; she was Jove's daughter and she was so foul and wicked in lust that she copulated with her own brother, or so the men say, through the devil's teaching, and the heathens also worshipped that evil woman as an exalted woman.

Wulfstan's copying of Æfric's work was only fair, since Ælfric himself based his version on a 6th-century sermon by Martin of Braga. Let's check out Martin tomorrow and see what else he did.

02 November 2026

Euhemerism

I said yesterday that I was going to talk about the writings of Ælfric of Eynsham, and I will, but I want to explain the term Euhemerism first. Euhemerism is an attempt to shed light on mythology by interpreting it as springing from actual historical events. Or, in the words of an American historian, it is "the taking of a cosmic god and placing him at a definite point in history as an actual person who was later deified." 

It assumes that real events became exaggerated and fictionalized in the oral transmission. The term comes from a late 4th-century BCE Greek, Euhemerus, who tried to rationalize mythology. Many early Greek philosophers were in agreement. In Plato's Phaedrus, Socrates offers an explanation of the story of an Athenian princess "taken away" by the north wind, Boreas. Socrates points out the place where there is a temple to Boreas where a wind might have knocked a young woman off her feet and onto rocks where she was killed.

Early Christian apologists used Euhemerism against paganism by declaring:

That those are no gods whom the common people worship, is known from this: they were formerly kings, who on account of their royal memory subsequently began to be adored by their people even in death. Thence temples were founded to them; thence images were sculptured to retain the countenances of the deceased by the likeness; and men sacrificed victims, and celebrated festal days, by way of giving them honour. Thence to posterity those rites became sacred, which at first had been adopted as a consolation.[from St. Cyprian]

The Middle Ages, and writers like Vincent of Beauvais and Roger Bacon, were willing to believe that supernatural beings were not imaginary, but were part of the natural order of things created by God. Men like Marsilius Ficino produced encyclopedic works to explain the hierarchy of demons, spirits, angels, archangels, etc., in God's creation.

Snorri Sturluson's Prose Edda (c.1220) paints the Norse gods as great leaders and kings, tracing back to that great foundation of so much medieval culture, the Trojan War.

The Modern Era also sometimes looks for historic origins of legendary characters, exaggerating them. Dracula, Paul Bunyan, Robin Hood—searching for the kernel of truth that grew into a legend.

But tomorrow we'll talk about Ælfric of Eynsham. Promise.

01 November 2026

Ælfric of Eynsham

The oldest sample in writing of Old Dutch happens to be scrawled in the margin of a manuscript stored in the Bodleian Library in Oxford. The manuscript in which it sits is a copy of the Homilies of Ælfric of Eynsham.

Ælfric (c. 955 – c. 1010) was English and educated as a Benedictine. When the Abbey of Cerne was finished, Ælfric was sent to teach the Benedictine monks there. While there he became friends with the abbey's chief benefactor, the ealdorman Æthelmær the Stout, and Æthelmær's father, Æthelweard.

While at Cerne, Ælfric thought to write a series of homilies, he says because he found errors in existing writings.

I Ælfric, monk and mass-priest, ..., was sent, in king Æthelred's day, from bishop Ælfeah, Æthelwold's successor, to a minster which is called Cerne, at the prayer of Æthelmær the thane, whose birth and goodness are known everywhere. Then it occurred to my mind, I trust through God's grace, that I would turn this book from the Latin language into the English tongue; not from confidence of great learning, but because I have seen and heard of much error in many English books, which unlearned men, through their simplicity, have esteemed as great wisdom: and I regretted that they knew not nor had not the evangelical doctrines among their writings...

After writing two series of homilies, he wrote three works to help students learn Latin, basing a Latin grammar on the works of Priscian and Donatus. He wrote a grammar, a glossary (with words in groups by subject, not alphabetical order), and a colloquy, a conversational work to help students learn to speak Latin naturally.

He then wrote a Lives of the Saints, attached to which are two more homilies, including De falsis deis ("on false gods"). This work discusses the ongoing battle between Christianity and the religious beliefs of the native Anglo-Saxons and the Danish invaders. It tries to put the pagan beliefs into a Christian framework.

The "of Eynsham" that is usually attached to his name came about when Æthelmær asked him in 1005 to become the first abbot of a new monastery created by Æthelmær, at Eynsham in Oxfordshire.

Tomorrow I want to share some of the details in his writings. In the meantime, you can read some yourself with the Latin and a Modern English translation side-by-side at the Gutenberg Project.